The Bookish Ashley

Rating: 4/5 Stars

Jennifer Peel’s Merry Little Hate Notes is a delightful holiday romance filled with wit, nostalgia, and just the right amount of angst to keep you turning the pages late into the night. It’s a story that tugs at your heartstrings, makes you laugh out loud, and reminds you of the thin line between love and hate—especially when that line involves your brother’s best friend.

The Plot

The story revolves around Holly St. James, who does everything in her power to avoid her past. That past includes Brandon Cassidy, her brother’s best friend, first kiss, and current coworker. Holly’s holiday season gets complicated when she’s forced to assist Brandon at work, a task she greets with a mix of dread and simmering attraction. Brandon, however, sees this as his chance to mend the mistakes of his youth—including letting Holly believe their sweet sixteen kiss was part of a cruel dare.

What sets the tone for the book is the revival of their childhood “hate note game,” where the two exchange cheeky (and sometimes heartfelt) notes. Through these letters, their complex dynamic unravels, revealing layers of hurt, longing, and unspoken love.

What Worked

1. The Characters:

• Holly is relatable and resilient, her wariness of Brandon stemming from a very real hurt.

• Brandon is charming and persistent, striking the perfect balance between redemption arc and swoony hero.

2. The Hate Note Game:

The notes themselves add a playful, nostalgic element that perfectly complements the festive backdrop. They also allow the characters to communicate in a way they struggle to face-to-face, which adds emotional depth.

3. Holiday Vibes:

The festive setting serves as a magical backdrop for their story, with plenty of twinkle lights, office parties, and cozy winter moments to enhance the romance.

4. The Banter:

Peel’s dialogue is sharp and witty, making the chemistry between Holly and Brandon palpable. Their push-pull dynamic feels authentic and keeps the tension alive.

What Could Have Been Better

While the story is heartwarming, it occasionally feels predictable. Some readers might wish for a twist or two to keep them guessing. Additionally, Brandon’s backstory and apology could have been fleshed out more to deepen the emotional payoff.

Final Thoughts

Merry Little Hate Notes is a feel-good holiday romance perfect for fans of second-chance love stories. Peel expertly balances humor and heart, making it easy to root for Holly and Brandon’s happily ever after. If you’re looking for a swoony, festive read with plenty of holiday cheer and a dash of playful rivalry, this book delivers.

Would I recommend it? Absolutely. Grab a cozy blanket, some hot cocoa, and enjoy this merry little romance that proves love sometimes starts with a well-penned hate note.