Book Review: Everyone in My Family Has Killed Someone by Benjamin Stevenson

Rating: ★★★☆☆ (3/5)

Benjamin Stevenson’s “Everyone in My Family Has Killed Someone” opens with an irresistibly morbid premise: every member of the Cunningham family is guilty of murder. The protagonist, Ernest Cunningham (call him Ern or Ernie), introduces us to his peculiar family and their dark pasts. The setup for the family reunion at a ski resort is intriguing, filled with promises of suspense, mystery, and dark humor.

Ernie’s narration is engaging, filled with wit and a touch of cynicism. He doesn’t shy away from revealing his own crime, adding a layer of personal involvement that keeps readers hooked. The novel unfolds like a twisted family saga, each murder coming to light in unexpected ways.

The idea of a family where everyone has killed someone is both darkly humorous and gripping. It immediately sets the novel apart from typical mystery thrillers. Ernie’s voice is distinctive and enjoyable. His dry humor and candidness make him a relatable, if not entirely reliable, narrator. The interactions between family members are well-drawn, showcasing a mix of tension, grudging affection, and old resentments that feel authentic.

However, the novel sometimes drags, especially in the middle sections where the focus shifts from the murders to the family’s interpersonal drama. This can make it difficult to maintain the initial excitement. With so many characters and their respective crimes, it can be challenging to keep track of who did what. Some readers might find the web of murders more confusing than compelling. The ending, while surprising, may not satisfy everyone. The build-up promises more than the conclusion delivers, leaving some threads feeling unresolved or rushed.

“Everyone in My Family Has Killed Someone” is a solid entry into the mystery genre with a refreshingly unique concept. However, it falls short of its full potential due to pacing issues and a somewhat convoluted plot. If you enjoy dark humor and complex family dynamics, this book might just hit the spot for you. For others, it may be a mixed bag—entertaining but not entirely satisfying.

Would I continue the series? Possibly. There’s enough here to pique my curiosity about where Stevenson will take the Cunningham family next, but I’d hope for a tighter narrative in the follow-up.

Have you read “Everyone in My Family Has Killed Someone”? Share your thoughts in the comments below!