The Bookish Ashley

“You Shouldn’t Have Come Here” by Jeneva Rose weaves a captivating tale of romance, suspense, and unexpected twists. The narrative takes us on a journey with Grace Evans, a New Yorker seeking respite from her hectic life in the peaceful embrace of a Wyoming ranch.

The story kicks off with a promising start as Grace arrives at Calvin Wells’ ranch, a picturesque escape from the hustle and bustle. The chemistry between Grace and Calvin is palpable, and the idyllic setting sets the stage for a charming romance. However, as the plot thickens, so does the sense of unease.

The author skillfully introduces elements of mystery, incorporating a lack of cell phone service, a missing woman, and an overall eerie atmosphere on the ranch. These elements add layers to the narrative, keeping readers on the edge of their seats. The pacing is well-executed, with the story gradually building tension as Grace’s suspicions grow.

The character development is a strong suit in this novel. Grace’s evolution from seeking an escape to confronting unexpected challenges is portrayed with depth. Similarly, Calvin’s character undergoes intriguing transformations, blurring the lines between infatuation and obsession.

As the romance deepens, the plot takes unexpected turns, leading to a complex web of lies and deceit. The author masterfully navigates the fine line between a playful romance and a darker, more sinister reality. The twists and revelations keep readers engaged, wondering how the tumultuous relationship between Grace and Calvin will unfold.

However, the book loses some momentum towards the end as the complexities pile up. The resolution feels slightly rushed, leaving a few loose ends untied. A more nuanced exploration of certain plot points could have enhanced the overall impact of the story.

In conclusion, “You Shouldn’t Have Come Here” offers an engaging mix of romance and mystery, with well-crafted characters and a gripping storyline. While the ending may leave some wanting more closure, the journey through the Wyoming ranch is a thrilling ride that will keep readers hooked until the final page.

Rating: 3.75/5 stars

Nathan Hill’s “Wellness” takes readers on a nostalgic journey from the gritty ’90s Chicago art scene to the complexities of suburban married life. The novel follows Jack and Elizabeth as they evolve from college art enthusiasts to navigating the challenges of parenting, health pursuits, and home renovations.

The narrative provides an insightful exploration of how individuals change over the years, especially in the context of a long-term relationship. Hill skillfully portrays the struggles of Jack and Elizabeth, who find themselves in the midst of suburban chaos while attempting to hold onto the vibrant, youthful dreams of their past.

The characterization is a strong point, with Jack and Elizabeth undergoing significant personal growth and facing the demons of unfulfilled career ambitions and memories of dysfunctional families. The challenges they encounter in their pursuit of wellness, from polyamorous suitors to home-renovation chaos, add a layer of humor and relatability to the story.

However, the pacing of the novel tends to fluctuate, with certain sections feeling a bit disjointed. The transitions between the ’90s art scene and suburban family life could have been smoother, making it easier for readers to connect with the characters’ evolving identities.

The themes of self-discovery and personal excavation are well-executed, but at times, the narrative becomes weighed down by the multitude of challenges faced by Jack and Elizabeth. This can make it challenging for readers to fully immerse themselves in the central message of the story.

In conclusion, “Wellness” by Nathan Hill offers a reflective exploration of adulthood, relationships, and the pursuit of happiness. While the characters’ journey is filled with relatable struggles and moments of humor, the uneven pacing and occasional narrative clutter may leave readers yearning for a more streamlined experience. Despite its flaws, “Wellness” succeeds in capturing the essence of evolving relationships and the complexities of navigating life’s twists and turns.

Rating: 3/5 stars